I think you didn't understand the purpose of it. Anyone with any sort of knowledge of Tribal Wars knows that the vast majority of top 20 tribes never make it very far. To take W87 which I duke on, only three of the top 40 tribes at start up made it to late-game, of which all three were premades with players who were easily recognisable. You can see similar trends on W88-W92 in terms of the correlation between a quick scan of a memberlist and how well they do in the world. Of course there are exceptions to the rule, but actually what I did in the video, whilst judgemental, may well be the best way to judge tribes at this stage of the game. This wasn't the case in older worlds, but is becoming more and more so nowadays unfortunately due to the centralisation of quality players and the lower player base.
The whole video was supposed to be a bit tongue in cheek though, I actually get along with a lot of the people I shouted out in the video, I talk to Ghio regularly and have played with him before though my criticisms made I do standby as somewhat valid though overexaggerated for comedic effect and I play in TEA on W90 for example. Most of what I said in the video is strictly true, I could go through individually with reasoning player to player but at this point of the game it is not worth it. The main purpose anyways was to get people out of the woodwork so to speak and put a bit of life into the forums by stirring people up and provoking responses. Yesterday the forums only had one thread and it was an introduction one, now there are two.
I'd be more than happy to refer you to pages of analysis I've made on this game, there are very few people nowadays who do more of that sort of content than myself. Similarly, if you wish to have a history, I am happy to put up, so to speak. I've won 9 worlds and been in the winning tribe of 2 more worlds before I quit. Of those, 3 of those tribes I founded and led personally either fully or partially. I could not name the number of rank 1 accounts or rank 1 tribes I have played in over my 10 years of playing since it's gotten to the point I've stopped counting. Normally I would not mention it, since it is really just pointless e-peen comparing, but since you wanted me to put up, then I have done so. If you had a better history than me as you claim above, then you would just be nodding your head and agreeing with most of what I am saying in that video although I do admit there was a bit of skimming.
I should say before I go, I only ever flame people's ability to play the game and everything I say is completely in-game related and you can go back through and double check if you wish. Trashtalk and banter is common to most games and sports and relatively common on the public forums also. I do not insult someone's punctuation whilst simultaneously using incorrect punctuation myself or try and insult someone's voice, though I'm not entirely sure whether calling someone stoned is supposed to be an insult when they are stoned. That I believe is the domain of that bully you are describing.