So from all the words, i can clearly see this :-
You have never fought him so have no idea how good/bad he maybe
You have never been in a tribe with him, for any real amount of time, so you are unable to judge certain aspects.
You have been critical of allos? words to the point where you say, you have never been IG with this player so how can your words be true.
This is the same thing, you are guessing saying, it shows this leadership trait. How so? It is still early to really say that.
clearly you can't see what I'm posting then. I never spoke about his skill level, so why do you keep saying I have?
Of course I can't judge certain aspects because I've never been in a tribe with him. I can judge certain aspects that are clearly evident to the outside world. I have no idea how he treats his members, how he organizes op's, how he motivates his members etc. I can judge nobling's that I see on twstats. If these villages were gifted to him, he's still fully capable of handing them out to other people. Players that quit aren't really in the position to demand as to who takes their villages. It's nice to gift and give directions, but they don't need to be followed.
I have been in game with this player. I played with him in w50. I've seen him post all over the externals, and gotten to know his personality well. I was in leadership in w50 that had to deal with him on a regular basis. This helps me form my opinion of his character, and helps me interpret his
current performance. I'm not criticizing his performance in w50. I'm criticizing his performance
here.
It does show a leadership trait, that's not a guess. I am guessing as to whether or not its actually true, but that type of performance is a trait nonetheless. I agree it is early to say that, and I can't guess the future as you keep telling me. I can however judge him on is his
current performance. If he ends up proving me wrong in the future, all the more power to him.
There have been 16 internals from rogues, looking at the map most have gone to those close. So your point about they should be handed out fairly is happening. Meaning the point you are making is rather a mute one. You just wanted something else to say and try to make allos? look bad, but after looking in to all the things you say about how to make it fair. I have noticed that all internals have been handed out in a fair manner.
So really the main point of this thread is to talk about w50 rather then w53. There has been no real discussion about w53 just what you have seen in w50. That has really no relevance to this world as the w50 set up is the complete opposite of the w53 set up.Maybe give the " i seen this in w50" a break and judge on w53. If you will judge on w53 please do the leg work to see if you have a valid point.
The point you make about internals is and allos? is way off the mark from looking at all internals to locations. There were 12 internals before you see allos? taking any and also some were not too far away from him but they were handed to others to aid there growth. And if you look at k56 locations of the main 4 rogue players im certain you will see 1 holds the south border to k55, 2 hold the middle border of k55/56 and 1 the north (which is where allos? took internals). So to me him taking those makes absolute sence as we have 4 good solid holding the border there. The location of those villages was quite key to have a nice border force.
You first start by saying the internals are generally nearby, and then in the next paragraph you say they are moving to secure the borders. Which one is it? I'm not criticizing anyone for moving to protect borders or anything of the sort. I'm criticizing him for doing it himself. He's taken another internal since I originally posted, and I'm reasonably confident he's about to take 2 more. A different strategy would be to have 2 players noble 3 villages each, and then expand in the area. This is a great way of diversifying your border so that opponents can't just op one person and overwhelm them. It's a wonderful defensive strategy. When I looked at the map of your tribe, I see a clear channel for him to move towards the border without having to jump over to internals. There are other players that could probably use it more effectively, possibly Kredulii who I can see is starting to get smothered. I'm not saying you need to do what I'm saying. I'm just saying from an outside perspective it seems as if he's
currently being selfish with internals which I have also seen in other worlds.
For reference, here's a map of your top 8
Everything I have said is about his
current performance on w50. Saying "
you sucked on w50" is not the same as "
I saw you suck on w50, and so far you're continuing that trend here". (this isn't what I'm saying, it's just an example) Everyone starts forming opinions from the moment you are introduced to someone, so how is it wrong to base it on another world as long as your description is explained by their
current performance?
+69
Everyone always says leave past worlds in the past but the same people that say that are the same ones that rip apart allos? for things that happened on W50. Judge people on this world.
People keep saying "this is w53, not w50". I didn't post his internal noblings on w50, I posted his internal noblings
on w53. I'm not criticizing him for his performance on w50 (other than him being banned for cheating, which left me with zero respect for him) I'm criticizing his
continued performance on this world. People change regularly. Look at faaaaarkles, he's done a generally great job of staying light humored and relaxed (except when I post :icon_redface
. When people clearly
don't change, it's a valid point of criticism. One last time: I'm criticizing his
current performance on this world, which is simply an extension of his
previous performance. My opinion of him started being formed on w50, and is continually evolving as this world goes on.
