Catapults?

DeletedUser

Guest
i seem to have noticed lately that sometimes where catapults hit a village they seem to not destroy a building that was targeted when it does indeed exist in that village. Would anyone know why a catapult would not do its job and not destroy buildings?Has it happened to you as well or am i just unlucky?
 

DeletedUser59417

Guest
Did you use more then 5-10 catapults? Some times it takes a number of catapults to lower a building. For instance an academy or level 20 smithy is more resilient to catapult attack then the market or rally point. if you are having trouble destroying the rally point then maybe its a glitch, but otherwise just use more catapults to destroy a building. If over 30 catapults did not lower a target i guess it could be unlucky i don't know the exact % but anything over 30 should lower most any building if they got through the players defensive troops.
 

DeletedUser108799

Guest
Another thing is if you akm for the
Church than it needs more catapults and if it is first church than it cannot be destroyed.
 
crimsoni

crimsoni

Contributing Poster
Reaction score
350
knightbrad said:
For instance an academy or level 20 smithy is more resilient to catapult attack then the market or rally point.
Click to expand...
You can take out an academy with 2 cats.

Here's a nice chart for reference:

cats_l10.png
 

DeletedUser

Guest
i am starting to think i am not using enough catapults since 5 seems to lower a building level but 2 or 3 do jack all to buildings it seems.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser59417

Guest
yes, 5-10 is the magic number of cat.

I would never cat an academy. Mostly farm is the best target. some times i cat the rally point before a train lands thats about it.
 

DeletedUser59417

Guest
crimsoni said:
You can take out an academy with 2 cats.

Here's a nice chart for reference:

cats_l10.png
Click to expand...

I never attack the academy as i normally like to have that when i noble a town, but i thought for sure 5 or 10 cat to lower academy.
 

mattcurr

Guest
knightbrad said:
I never attack the academy as i normally like to have that when i noble a town, but i thought for sure 5 or 10 cat to lower academy.
Click to expand...

All buildings with exception of level 1 hq, level 1 warehouse, level 1 farm, and churches take the same number of cats doesn't matter what building only matters the level.

The chart is assuming no defenders. For accurate information with defenders use the simulator . In fact if you use the simulator it is 100 percent accurate so you guys wouldn't need to ask silly questions
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Yes but filling in a few boxes with numbers is harder than coming here and writing words and hoping someone else will sort it out for you
 

DeletedUser112872

Guest
I don't think the cat tables above are accurate for this world. Of course, the tables can always be awry if there is a real imbalance of defensive power, but (per the simulator) a two cat attack won't lower a 1 to 0, much less a 2 to 1.

From memory, all the way back to world 23 (my start) the tables look right. I haven't played in a couple of years, since world 50 something.

I think these are correct on W70

[/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
generated in 93 ms | Server time: 2:48:13 25/10/2013

1-0 4 4
2-1 4 8
3-2 5 13
4-3 5 18
5-4 5 23
6-5 6 29
7-6 6 35
8-7 7 42
9-9 7 49
10-9 8 57
11-10 8 65
12-11 9 74
13-12 10 84
14-13 11 95
15-14 11 106
16-15 12 118
17-16 13 131
18-17 15 146
19-18 16 162
20-19 17 179
21-20 19 198
22-21 20 218
23-22 22 240
24-23 24 264
25-24 26 290
26-25 29 319
27-26 31 350
28-27 34 384
29-28 37 421
30-29 40 461

Cat TablesIf you can clear most defense as you attack, and level the wall (although even with some defense [check per-case in your simulator] still alive cats triumph with minimal offense), the following shows the effectiveness of hitting with subsequent "cat trains."To bring a 30 target to a 29 requires 40 cats. To bring a 40 target to zero using successive cat waves requires a total of 461 cats in 30 attacks.Conversely, the same 461 cats sent at once to a 30 target will only lower it to a 24. It would require 2349 cats sent all at once to bring a 30 to a 0.(Can you BUILD a cat nuke with 2349 nukes....I'm NOT spending the time to check, LOL)Luck does not affect the cat attacks.Target Cats CumulativeLevel Needed Cats(From-To) Needed1-0 4 42-1 4 83-2 5 134-3 5 185-4 5 236-5 6 297-6 6 358-7 7 429-9 7 4910-9 8 5711-10 8 6512-11 9 7413-12 10 8414-13 11 9515-14 11 10616-15 12 11817-16 13 13118-17 15 14619-18 16 16220-19 17 17921-20 19 19822-21 20 21823-22 22 24024-23 24 26425-24 26 29026-25 29 31927-26 31 35028-27 34 38429-28 37 42130-29 40 461
Available characters: 58586
BB-codes
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser112872

Guest
Sorry- I can't get what I wrote to copy and post correctly. Data should be correct, but looks horrible
 

DeletedUser

Guest
oldguye61 said:
I don't think the cat tables above are accurate for this world. Of course, the tables can always be awry if there is a real imbalance of defensive power, but (per the simulator) a two cat attack won't lower a 1 to 0, much less a 2 to 1
Click to expand...

The cat table is accurate; have used it for several cat trains on this world. Are you making sure the cats don't die in the sim?

-A
 

DeletedUser

Guest
blakeomega said:
i seem to have noticed lately that sometimes where catapults hit a village they seem to not destroy a building that was targeted when it does indeed exist in that village. Would anyone know why a catapult would not do its job and not destroy buildings?Has it happened to you as well or am i just unlucky?
Click to expand...

i had this happen to me today like they missed or something :/

http://en70.tribalwars.net/public_report/7db15a557321abe3b1f1311d272c6217

when i aim at the farm again they take it down no levels

http://en70.tribalwars.net/public_report/bfb1d8c97859320b3d49ca222c88fbed
 

DeletedUser59417

Guest
Wait you attacked justincase thats my insurance guy!

justin case/just-in-case.

i don't like clowns. i am glad your catapults failed.

you should not be attacking with such low troop count anyways.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Join date: 06th October 2013
oda 22.468
i've lost 2300+ axes clearing people and my 50x50 isn't competitive so i'm just keeping my church radius cleared till someone's worth nobling, so i see no problem attacking with my troop count plus that was about 5% of my lc count
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top