L-C,
Really, I just checked the posted players above and actually started laughing. Most have at least 4 tribe changes (2 having 9 or more)?
Let look closer:
Kettco - 4 changes, 230K acct w/ rank 348 OD (weak OD rating, not much of a warrior)
Karlos - 10 changes, 264K acct w/ rank 147 OD (stronger warrior but tribe hopper, personally, he'd not have private forum priv's if I was lead)
london - 5 changes, 151K acct w/ rank 1101 OD (OD is a joke, has he actually sent an axe to a real target?)
Skar - 3 changes, 195K w/ rank 757 OD (again, can he or will he actually attack someone with skill?)
Stevie - 5 changes, 258K acct w/ rank 364 OD (wow, thought he was at war?)
Nutter - 9 tribe changes (didn't expect this), 385K acct w/ rank 258 OD (again, at war and 258 OD? wow)
King - mostly assimilated and internally nobled (don't see how Orphan caused this)
Whipx - mostly assimilated and internally nobled (don't see how Orphan caused this)
As for breaking a tribe, in this nubs view, something above indicates three things:
1. Orphan recruited players that haven't any loyalty to their tribe
2. Orphan's recruiting policy is rather weak and obviously values points over active envolvement
3. You are trumpeting Orphan's greatness and really have yet to show us anything.
Just my perspective but then again I'm a neutral party nub here.