is it smart

DeletedUser25046

Guest
Your offensive villages can hold off one or two attacks? This I'd like to see.
yes because i have so many defensive villages to offensive villages i am able to send smal ammount of defense from each to all of my offesive villages which usually adds up to 4K sp, 4K sw, 4K ar and 2.5K HC

Attacker
Units:0 0 7000 0 0 3250 0 0 250 0 0 0
Losses:0 0 7000 0 0 3250 0 0 250 0 0 0
Defender
Units:4000 4000 0 4000 0 0 0 2500 0 0 0 0
Losses:2346 2346 0 2346 0 0 0 1466 0 0 0 0

Attacker
Units:0 0 7000 0 0 3250 0 0 2500 0 0
Losses:0 0 4355 0 0 1000 0 0 1560 0 0
Defender
Units:1654 1654 0 1654 0 0 0 1034 0 0 0 0
Losses:1654 1654 0 1654 0 0 0 1034 0 0 0 0


which by my calculation will hold off the beter part of two nukes under nuetral luck and 100% morality. i didn't even bother including my nuke it there but that might change this just slightly if my nuke gets caught in the cross fire.
 

pyker42

Guest
And how many troops does that leave you with in all your defensive villages?

(Just out of idle curiosity)
 

Coma Faith

Guest
yes because i have so many defensive villages to offensive villages i am able to send smal ammount of defense from each to all of my offesive villages which usually adds up to 4K sp, 4K sw, 4K ar and 2.5K HC

Attacker
Units:0 0 7000 0 0 3250 0 0 250 0 0 0
Losses:0 0 7000 0 0 3250 0 0 250 0 0 0
Defender
Units:4000 4000 0 4000 0 0 0 2500 0 0 0 0
Losses:2346 2346 0 2346 0 0 0 1466 0 0 0 0

Attacker
Units:0 0 7000 0 0 3250 0 0 2500 0 0
Losses:0 0 4355 0 0 1000 0 0 1560 0 0
Defender
Units:1654 1654 0 1654 0 0 0 1034 0 0 0 0
Losses:1654 1654 0 1654 0 0 0 1034 0 0 0 0


which by my calculation will hold off the beter part of two nukes under nuetral luck and 100% morality. i didn't even bother including my nuke it there but that might change this just slightly if my nuke gets caught in the cross fire.
Yes, because this will all get there, from all over your cluster, before a next-door nuke.

You've forgotten what you were arguing about, didn't you?
 

DeletedUser25046

Guest
dude it's already there!
and what that leaves me with is 5K in my defensive villages and 1.5K HC
which i enter weave as some i build more spears and others more swords in.
 

Irishmetal

Guest
dude it's already there!
and what that leaves me with is 5K in my defensive villages and 1.5K HC
which i enter weave as some i build more spears and others more swords in.
With that kinda ratio of troops, you must have a negligible offense.
 

pyker42

Guest
dude it's already there!
and what that leaves me with is 5K in my defensive villages and 1.5K HC
which i enter weave as some i build more spears and others more swords in.
I'm calling BS right now.

First and foremost, 5k sp/sw/ar and 1.5k HC = a total population space of 24,000

I don't even need to go any farther with this, timjons.
 

DeletedUser25046

Guest
i didn't say they 5K each i only pick 2 units to build in each village so it's either spears here or swords here and archers in all.
 

Irishmetal

Guest
i didn't say they 5K each i only pick 2 units to build in each village so it's either spears here or swords here and archers in all.
Well that's the stupidest thing I've ever heard. I would love you as an enemy.
 

pyker42

Guest
i didn't say they 5K each i only pick 2 units to build in each village so it's either spears here or swords here and archers in all.
Ok, so running off your earlier statements, you build roughly a 3:1 D:O village ratio. So, lets say you have 100 villages. Using a generous 21,000 population space for troops, that means you have roughly 1,575,000 defensive troops. Of that you claim to keep roughly 1,425,000 troops in your defensive villages.

So, that leaves you with 150,000 defensive troops to cover 25 offensive villages.

Yet, your stated permanent defense stationed in offensive villages comes out to a total population of 27,000. Which, times 25 villages is 675,000 troops. So, how do you account for the 525,000 shortfall in population space? (Mind you, even if all your defensive villages were pop bonus villages and had no farm space taken up by buildings, your population wouldn't be enough to cover the shortfall.)
 

DeletedUser25046

Guest
i don't know where you get that i don't know where you're getting 1.425 mil my math shows me only 1.254 million.
going by what i put and using 66 villages as the 3:1 would have it.

but what you don't realize as you probably wil dissagree with this method but each of my offensive village has 3K defense of its own which i do belive in total adds up to the shortage. also take into account that my 4 or 5 recently nobled villages would have that stack set up yet.
 
Last edited:

pyker42

Guest
i don't know where you get that i don't know where you're getting 1.425 mil my math shows me only 1.254 million.
going by what i put and using 66 villages as the 3:1 would have it.

but what you don't realize as you probably wil dissagree with this method but each of my offensive village has 3K defense of its own which i do belive in total adds up to the shortage. also take into account that my 4 or 5 recently nobled villages would have that stack set up yet.
You said that you have 75% defensive villages. That means for every 4 villages, you have 3 defensive, and 1 offensive. That is a ration of 3:1. :icon_rolleyes:

And, you are an engineer? How did you get an engineering degree if you can't perform simple multiplication?

Even with 3k defense of its own in your offensive villages, that is only 75,000 more population. That doesn't account for the short fall when you add in the building space of your defensive villages, and the fact that I'm sure most of them are not pop bonus villages.

Further, taking away 3k of space from your offensive is about the stupidest thing you can do, although I shouldn't be surprised.

Seriously, you need to just quit. If you are in America, the hole you are digging yourself has almost reached the Indian Ocean.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

pyker42

Guest
Why is it already there?

Because you sent it after they scouted the village?

Thank you for proving my point.
No, because he keeps it there all the time, according to him.

Of course, his figures are wildly unrealistic. :lol:
 

Coma Faith

Guest
So he has 18K defence in every village.

And he has offence too..

See what you mean ;)
 

Coma Faith

Guest
Only 27K?

I have 9001K in my offence vills, that's how the pros play :icon_cool:
 

DeletedUser25046

Guest
Only 27K?

I have 9001K in my offence vills, that's how the pros play :icon_cool:
so you keep 9001K defensive troops in everyone of your offensive vilages leaving under a -10K in all your defensive ones or do you have 1 million villages?
 

Coma Faith

Guest
I have 69,000,000 villages, and the ability to detect sarcasm <3
 

DeletedUser25046

Guest
perhaps you can help me out on that one how can you detect sarcasim over the internet ifs it not specifically mentioned.