No, i'm simply saying that a bad player doesn't go from being a bad player to the world's best player inside a year. He's clearly not a noob if he's played since w8.net.
Anyway, here's my thoughts:
Best Player: e10100111001 - assuming Duff is still playing there seriously, which is likely judging from the stats, then i'm suprised this account isn't being mentioned more.
Most overrated player: Jammer0 - For reasons stated above.
Favourite Player: e10100111001 - He won't recognise me on this alias, but anyone that loves ODA as much as this guy has to be worth liking.
Best tribe: Ya Bro - Just took rank 1, and i fully expect them to be there or there abouts in some capacity come mid-end game.
Most promising tribe for future: *SP* - Who?!?!, I hear you cry. You'll know about us soon, our alias' are working for now
Best leader: Too early to say because none have been tested yet, but because he's got proven experience i'll go with balubhai.
Worst leader: Again, too early to judge from this world, but if xtcwarrior1 is leading TBS here, then i urge his members to get out whilst they still can.
Favorite forum poster: Dk - The newspaper is(was?) great, and i can count on 1 hand the number of other interesting posts here.
Lamest forum poster: That Tomb Raider chick. Sorry i don't know you, but your posts' always make me laugh or facepalm, and never for good reasons.
Best COA in game: No idea, and i couldn't care less.
Most overrated tribe: Doubt - Sorry guys, some really good players and good friends here, but from what i know of your bad ones, these guys have proven weak links that other tribes could exploit.
Most underrated tribe: AV - I'm still sticking by these guys, despite nobody agreeing with me. I'm not sure why their good players havn't been mentioned yet, but anyone that has played previous early worlds with about half a dozen of these guys, will know that they definately have the skill amongst their members list to cause some big suprises. I can't comment on the leadership though, and perhaps that'll be the deciding factor eventually.