opinions

johnny789

Guest
my first few attempts at making sigs, can I get opinions/advice please.

pre_1441372783__untitled9.jpg


pre_1441305450__first_sig.jpg


pre_1441305507__untitled1.jpg


pre_1441307828__untitled5.jpg


pre_1441316327__untitled6.gif


pre_1441405411__ninja.gif


pre_1441382185__untitled10.png


pre_1441446381__unti.png






I only learnt yesterday so they are probably awful ^^
 
Last edited:

DeletedUser118286

Guest
First one:

There's a roundish white space on the left. Seems kind of awkward.

2nd one looks pretty good but certain parts seem a little too oversharpened.

3rd one makes my vision weird...It's really good but if it wasn't GIFed, then I would say its the best out of all three
 

johnny789

Guest
Thanks for the response man, I too noticed the things you mentioned... I will try not to make the same mistakes twice now :)

hehe, the white space is a fractal of a planet, it may have worked better with some transparency..

And the 3rd as a still image:

pre_1441307828__untitled5.jpg


That was my 2nd attempt at cutting a render, can maybe see on the left of the character it isn't cut properly so I GIFed it to try and hide that ^^

Really need to work on my fonts also, but I am enjoying the learning process;GFX rox

Thanks :)
 

DeletedUser65288

Guest
Just a heads up, .gif sigs are against the forum rules (feel free to make them, but you'll get told to take it out of your signature if it gets set).
 

johnny789

Guest
Why are my sigs not uploading to my account properly... I should have one activated at the moment
 
Top