Rate the player above you

CMBurns

Guest
Haven't seen this anywhere in this world yet, which surprises me as it's usually in every world.


Simple structure:

Player: /10 + reason
Points: /10 + reason
Tribe: /10 + reason
Position: /10 + reason
ODA/ODD: /10 + reason
 

HeftySmurf

Contributing Poster
Player: 9/10 - Good player, Rank 15 and looking good for it.
Points: 8/10 - Pointwhore :')
Tribe: 7/10 - Dont know much about them, but look strong in their position.
Position: 8/10 - Good controlled area
ODA/ODD: 9/10 - Rank 23, nuff said.

Ign is Smurfies for those who cant work it out.
 

sha1d

Member
Player: 8/10 - You look to be going strong, seem to be coming out ontop against some REL players
Points: 7/10 - Not the biggest player in your area, but still not too bad. Nobling 3 in 3 days quite good, and decent size nobles as well.
Tribe: 10/10 - My favourite tribe in this world. Should do well, though i want to see more action from them ;)
Position: 9/10 - Apart from the 2 villages in the middle of your tribe, you have seemed to have managed to relocate to the edge of your tribe allowing good growth.
ODA/ODD: 9/10 - Looks like you've been having some fun.

IGN: Sha1d
 

Amane.

Guest
Not big enough to really say

First thoughts, maybe not the most experienced player, but, only time can change that opinion..

No ODA is a concern.

IGN : Amane. yes including the period sign at the end.
 

zachary.2

Guest
Player: 9/10 - experienced player, does alot for the tribe : )
Points: 8/10 - you need to more like valth and pointwhore it up haha
Tribe: 10/10 - Cuz Punch! is L33t
Position: 7/10 - good spread, should come to the east of the k tho :)
ODA/ODD: 6/10 - rank 402, good, but nuke some more people

Ign, Never... (with the dots)
 

supersaad255

Guest
Player: 7/10 Looks decent, and is active on the forums
Points: 5/10 Too little :)
Tribe: 7/10 Good tribe, but yet to see the outcome of their war.
Position: 7/10 Near the border
ODA/ODD: 9 1/2 /10 Dude nice!


My IGN:

WEROCKWORLD54
 

Valth

Guest
Tribe: 7/10 Good tribe, but yet to see the outcome of their war.

Well i think we did quite a job considering its been only a week, you can check thread named for that war to see it?


Player: 6/10 - idk player personally but half of conquers are acc. merge, not cool
Points: 9/10 - very good
Tribe: 8/10 - I always have a bad thought about F, i really dont know why but they did good against cheese
Position: 10/10 - near border, have a lot of villages inside his cluster, just awesome positioning
ODA/ODD: 7/10 - could be better compared to size

IGN: V for Valth
 

Amane.

Guest
Player: 9/10 - 10/10 would mean perfect, I don't know of any such player.. :)
Points: 10/10 - Obvious nooby pointwhore
Tribe: 2/10 - Punch is crap :D Jokes 10/10 Love the place
Position: 7/10 - in and around borders, still, lots of villages make up for this downfall
ODA/ODD: 2/10 Point wore. :p


Amane.
 

awkward.turtle

Guest
Player: 7/10
Points: 7/10 Solid 500 rank. Not too bad, not too great.
Tribe: 5/10 Who are they?
Position: 7/10. Sea of gray barbs. Good for farming.
ODA/ODD: 7/10. Better than your rank. Usually a good sign.

awkward.turtle (go easy. just got out of beginner's protection a few hours ago. :p)
 

zachary.2

Guest
Player: 5/10 - seem, decent
Points: 4/10 - behind people in your 15x15
Tribe: 5/10 - decent, i guess?
Position: 2/10 - not great at all. you seem to be in a rough spot
ODA/ODD: 4/10 - epic Od of 20 :lol:

ign never... (with the dots)
 

huggies best 4 babies

Guest
i really want to do this but i don't have an account on w54 :(
 

awkward.turtle

Guest
The troops are where its at. But pointwise, give me a week to out-pace the people around me. :p

Player: 7/10 - Seems decent. What you lack in points, you make up in OD.
Points: 6/10 - Seems partially due to incoming attacks from other players?
Tribe: 9/10 - Seem good.
Position: 7/10
ODA/ODD: 9/10 - Great ODD. Get a little higher ODA and you might have gotten 10.

awkward.turtle
 

CMBurns

Guest
Player: 7/10 - You seem to know what you're doing as you defend.
Points: 6/10 - I'm guessing you're under heavy attacks, so it doesnt help the growth, but I'm sure you can grow more than that.
Tribe: 8/10 - Completely wild guess here, who doesn't like PUNCH! uh?
Position: 8/10 Seems to be alot of room for expansion, althought again with your ODD, it may be harder than it appears.
ODA/ODD: 10/10 Mainly ODD, but you're doing awesome in that department.


EDIT: this was for "Never..."
 

2dark

Guest
Player 9/10- complete picture is satisfactionary (is that a word?)
Points 9/10- 10/10 is reserved for top 10
tribe 10/10- small member count, good position seem to know what they are doing
position 8/10- seems to be in control
ODA/Odd- Oda-10/10, Odd 7/10 ODA is very good, lack or ODD means that you have not been challeged yet, or that you are good with defending with offense. Either way it is good.
 

zachary.2

Guest
Player: 7/10 - You seem to know what you're doing as you defend.
Points: 6/10 - I'm guessing you're under heavy attacks, so it doesnt help the growth, but I'm sure you can grow more than that.
Tribe: 8/10 - Completely wild guess here, who doesn't like PUNCH! uh?
Position: 8/10 Seems to be alot of room for expansion, althought again with your ODD, it may be harder than it appears.
ODA/ODD: 10/10 Mainly ODD, but you're doing awesome in that department.


EDIT: this was for "Never..."
my growth hasnt really been effected it by it, just nub nukes from angry.
lost 1 village and gained 2 since the start, lost my some of my nukes so gonna gain some Oda soon in the next few days : )


for 2dark


Player: 7/10 - seem alright.
Points: 8/10
Tribe: 6/10 - because of slow war with angry, you guys can do better, low member count and nice od tho.
Position: 7/10 - seems good enough, room to expand
ODA/ODD: 7/10 - rank 43, pretty nice. keep it up : )
 

Rudegar

Still Going Strong
Player: 9/10 - never isnt a player... hes an icon... 3/10 if not actually never for impersonating
Points: 7/10 - looks like a pita of a start from the ODD
Tribe: 8/10 - everyone seems to like em, and tbh they all seem pretty happy with their tribe... always a positive sign
Position: 7/10 - much of a muchness
ODA/ODD: 8/10 - oda mediocre but odd looks like you have attracted quite a bit of attention

ign... secretagentbarbie
 

zachary.2

Guest
Player: 9/10 - never isnt a player... hes an icon... 3/10 if not actually never for impersonating
ign... secretagentbarbie
he was playing the account, but quit due to rl last week ,now im left on the account alone :icon_cry:


Player: 8/10 - know what your doing , good player
Points: 9/10 - nice points : )
Tribe: 8/10 - seem like a good bunch, but, havnt seen them in a war yet, so not to sure yet, but for the most part good
Position: 7/10 - good positioning
ODA/ODD: 10/10 - rank 11 Oda, doing great i have to say
 

devicem

Guest
Player: secretagentbarbie

Player: 9/10 - based on stats, you look v.good. Perfect score would mean watching you in action. -.-
Points: 8/10 - Little over the top villages count for the number of points, but still good.
Tribe: 9/10 - decent, contender for the top3
Position: 8/10 - Current position suggests you have indeed good stretch, farming alone etc. Some of your villages look off the church radi, but it's only my opinion. -.-
ODA/ODD: 9/10 Way to go. Slaughter some more... ;P

IGN: devicem
 
Last edited by a moderator:

agullabell

Guest
devicem

9/10 you seem to be doing well against others the reason for not perfect is barb and inhouse noble .. aslo nice point average taken

10/10 ranked number good for this world so you deserve full credit for being where you are

0/10 sorry valth darling but this is only to tease you :) so since you are in punch you get 0 score ... blame valth for this he will only laugh and say its bell what do you expect

8/10 for postion but then its more then a pass so well done

5/10 for oda and od .. this should be improved giving your world ranking is less then your score here

ingame name hibakusha
 

microx

Guest
hibakusha

Player: 9/10 - A whopping rank three chicken.
Points: 10/10 - Rank 3, lovely. I want that account manager!
Tribe: 9/10 - Lovely. Hope to see you chicks in action in a nice war soon.
Position: 9/10 - Very nice spread, lots of potential.
ODA/ODD: 10/10 MASSACRE!

IGN microx