Rate the player

slates9

Guest
Give the player on top of you a rating in each category out of 10.


Points: /10

ODA: /10

Positioning: /10

Reputation: /10

Tribe: /10

Total: /50

Makes The Forums More Interesting

(From the .co.uk server but it's all over the .net server too)
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Not sure I know what you mean about on top of you...

Some wife/husband duos play this game...and so do some kids...
 

DeletedUser

Guest
He means the person who posted directly before you. :icon_wink:

Macready08

Points: 9/10 - Almost in the top 20, keep it up! :)

ODA: 10/10 - Very high OD, both offensive and defensive.

Positioning: 7/10 - Spread out among multiple continents, not very dense clusters.

Reputation: 9/10 - Most people would say his reputation is great, but recently there's been a few who disagree.

Tribe: 2/10 - Not bad for a 1-man tribe.

Total: 37/50
 
Last edited by a moderator:

slates9

Guest
Like that

AK_Iceman

Points: 7/10

ODA: 7/10

Positioning: 7/10

Reputation: 10/10

Tribe: 9/10

Total: 40/50
 

MR.MR

Guest
Come on, at least have the decency to explain your reasoning, I mean I could rate Baddie or Parm as 2/10 for everything and not explain and you couldn't question it because on my scale 2/10 could be phenomonal ;)
 

slates9

Guest
Fine. Let me redo mine


Like that

AK_Iceman

Points: 7/10
Closing in on that ever to pointless 1m.

ODA: 7/10
Nice ODA for points. Being in middle of tribe slowly runs out of targets within a decent distance

Positioning: 7/10
Right in the middle of a great tribe, but makes you run out of targets

Reputation: 10/10
C'mon, as if we don't know him

Tribe: 9/10
THE...'nough said

Total: 40/50
Overall a good all round player, with the ability to persuade and argue his point across, with troops to back it up
 

DeletedUser74538

Guest
Slates9

Points: 4/10

Not quite 500k

ODA: 6/10

Over twice his points, yet twice hit rank. (If that makes sense)


Positioning: 5/10

Havnt checked his clustering, however picked two of his villages to have a look at, and surrounded by much larger tribesmembers.

Reputation: 5/10

Havnt really seen/heard much from him so cant comment if good or bad, so steady 5.

Tribe: 7/10

Top 20, however relatively late start.

Total: 27/50

Above average.

EDIT: I take average as 5, so 25/50 would be an average player... etc, thats how I thought you gave things a rating out of ten.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser

Guest
heheheh do we already have an average....... if so I don't think that's above it. though I won't argue the marks I don't know this player. I'm just givin yah a hard time.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

slates9

Guest
I'm guess he's stating average as half marks. An btw, I'm clearly a 50/50 :icon_wink:
 

DeletedUser22924

Guest
might aswell make my own

abscindo

Points: 7/10 a bit larger than myself

ODA: 4/10 not much to show their

Positioning: 5/10 sepearte into 3 clusters, means u have more churches meaning u have less troops.

Reputation: 7/10 i like ur spunk

Tribe: 3/10 well they are not totally useless i guess

Total: 26/50 ur not bad, but not good either ur okay. :p
 

Crispycargo

Guest
Points: 7/10 - Could be better could be worse. Not bad though.

ODA: 7/10 - Decent ODA for your points... at least it's 2x.

Positioning: 7/10 - Looks like three main clusters from the map. However they are each pretty dense so it would be easy to stack\coordinate offensive operations with them.

Reputation: 8/10 - Although i don't really keep up on the southern wars, i've noticed that you seem to post quite a bit. Not sure how people feel about you though.

Tribe: 5/10 - Not too fond of family tribes(although that's very hypocritical of me to say) and it seems you guys arn't doing too hot in your wars judging from the stats.

Total: 34/50 - Pretty good considering the leader of the number #1 ranked tribe of this world only got a 40 ;)
 

DeletedUser

Guest
this world has had some time to develop, but we are just now seeing some interesting things happen as far as war's across the world, and very heated topics in a multitude of areas. so i dont want to score anyone to high.

Points: 8/10 decent points

ODA: 6/10 decent oda

Positioning: 8/10 decent well spread out cluster spreading well.

Reputation: 2/10 I dont pay attention to forums much but I havent seen you yet.

Tribe: 8/10 I like the name.

Total: 32/50 I would probably have scored you higher but I dont know much about you. a brief glance showed me a good player but I dont know =P.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
I will do you later fightclub, short on time atm.

lol.

IG name is toasta3000 :p

EDIT:
Fightclubx

Points: 9/10 This coming from somebody who has barely scratched the top 300 and never reached 1M, You look quite good not many villages >10k

ODA: 11/10 nearly 10x his points, nuff said.

Positioning: 5/10 one massive blob with several outposts, hate to see how many churches he would need to overlap to cover it all.

Reputation: 8/10 Not too well known, but what I have seen you are quite good :)

Tribe: 7/10 Not a TWC fan, sorry. family tribe, otherwise 10/10

Total: 40/50
 
Last edited by a moderator:

xinryr

Guest
toasta3000

Points: 8.5/10

I don't really care about points, to tell the truth. Yours seem decent.

ODA: 9/10

Good, about five times your points which is always a good sign ^^

Positioning: 6.5/10

From what I see you have two main cluster type things, then some other villages beyond, perhaps future clusters, I don't know. Really, if you can properly function I'm not sure that how you assemble your villages matters.

Reputation: 8/10

No one hates you from what I see, that's always good. You post moderately from what I've seen, as well.

Tribe: 10/10

Number five tribe in the world...only four other ways to beat that =)

Total: 42/50

Please don't take bad scores personally :)

I have a feeling my total score will be like 5 :D
 

fanbubub

Guest
xinryr

Points: 4/10 - not great, but not really awful.

ODA: 5/10 - better than your points, respectful enough.

Positioning: 5/10 - doing ok for where you are. K86 is my K on W12. It's a nice k^^

Reputation: 5/10 - (lots of 5's..) I've seen you post on the forums a few times, but not heard much about the way you play in-game.

Tribe: 3/10 - Rank 28 :/ Not really heard anything about them.

Total: 22/50 - I'm a n00b. Don't listen to my scores xD


I'm Arsena03 for the next person - NOT my forum name.
 

inflrc

Guest
Arsena03

Points:4/10 - Not top 100 and lately very inactive, no increase in points or OD. Once was rank 19, but now is rank 282.

ODA: 6/10 - Better than his points rank. His ODA is five times his points, obtained basically nobling players over 5000pts. No recent increase.

Positioning: 8/10 - Nice clustering: A tight main one close to a borderline and little one next to another borderline.

Reputation: 5/10 - First time that I see his name, but also I don't participate a lot in PnP.

Tribe: 8/10 - Crysis, top 13, ODA 12, ODD 11. CRY has uniform its points, has a good participation in PnP and seems to not be afraid of no one. His current enemy says they are a strong tribe, very capable.

Total: 31/50
 

DeletedUser

Guest
*Kudos to slates for a great forum topic*

inflrc

Points: 10/10 - Hes ranked 11th in w30 pretty good by my standards

ODA: 7/10 - He has an great ODA, but his ODD is a little low... 500k. So you either do great job striking first or people would rather not attack a top 11th player!

Positioning: 9/10 - Positioning is pretty good depending on who your allied too... Two good clusters, both on the outer edge of your tribe.

Reputation: 5/10 - Reputation... Not to sure, where i read the forums often, Im not familair with your name.

Tribe: 8/10 - Im basing that on rank, havent read much about decide... dont know much about them, but i know it takes a decent tribe to be in the top 5.

Total: 39/50
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser

Guest
Major*Payne

Points: 6.5/10 low rank 813th Given the location, k87 he would have started much later then I, having said that, looks like the area he started is very hostile toward him at present. Looks like he has tried, hence the .5 point.

ODA: 6/10 Low ranking here, 844th. however, seeing as he looks to be a defenceive player, ( most likey no choise in the matter ) I rank him a little higher out of fairness as his ODA is over 1 mio

Positioning: 8/10 I am impressed with this players clusters, they are better than mine by a long margin. not knowing what his church location is the, less churches he has the better off he will be.

Reputation: 5/10 Cannot say that this player has any reputation at all, but his area of the map may beg to differ.

Tribe: 5/10 WOR. Can honestly say i know little about them. they have taken a huge dive in points, could be a combo of being nobled, and players being dissmissed/quitting.

Total: 30.5/50 Not to shabby

See spoiler for some war stats

[spoil]Side 1:
Tribes:
Players: Pwnzorinc grandigon DCnuebe THEGUNN75 karing zephyrlove BONHEUR DCnuebe Lapatuska

Side 2:
Tribes:
Players: Major*Payne

Timeframe: Forever

Total conquers against opposite side:

Side 1: 22
Side 2: 13
Difference: 9

image.php


Points value of total conquers against opposite side:

Side 1: 196,271
Side 2: 111,645
Difference: 84,626

image.php

[/spoil]
 

DeletedUser65940

Guest
Fraseryeah

Points: 10/10 rank 34 - well done mate, anyone in the top 100 has a lot of dedication to the game.

ODA: 10/10 rank 6, can't compete with that, very offensive player

ODD: 10/10, rank 73, there arn't a lot of players who get attacked a lot as well as defend a lot. So well done on your defendings.

Positioning: 10/10 I am very impressed with your clusters, they are nice and dense, allowing quick support.

Reputation: 5/10 - to be honest, I have never heard of you, but that may differ the closer to your home K you get.

Tribe: 9/10. [CRY]. I have heard lots of [CRY], cant say I am an expert of them, but they are doing good to be in the top 20

Total: 54/60, nice job mate.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top