Rate the signature above

[DeletedUser]

Most worlds have one yet the graphic forum doesn't, seems silly to me so here goes , rate siggy only avatars aren't worth rating.

 

[DeletedUser]

It works on other worlds because people look there more. People here pretty much all have good signatures. And you'll be forced to rate 8+ every time. It just won't work.

 

[DeletedUser]

People here pretty much all have good signatures. And you'll be forced to rate 8+ every time. It just won't work.

Maybe we could just have higher expectations?

 

[DeletedUser]

Maybe we could just have higher expectations?

True. But when newb sig maker comes along, what to do?

 

[DeletedUser]

Erm... rate? What's the difference?

 

[DeletedUser]

Erm... rate? What's the difference?

Example:

A few sigs like this:

Then this:

Your rating the signatures highly right?

 

[mattoematt]

All those signatures are pretty bad actually..

GE:

Avy - 7/10
Signature - 9/10 (Simple, Unique)

 

[DeletedUser]

I don't like rating at all, I prefer verbal critique over numeric classification.

As an example though from top of my mind I'd rate the above sigs at 7, 6, 9.3 and 8 respectively.

Edit: Radarr (sorry, I can't spell that second name of yours correctly): 8/10

 

[mattoematt]

We practically use Signature Showcase as CnC although not many people actively use it.

 

[DeletedUser]

It doesn't really work well, as showcase is... well... showcase. A dedicated thread for CnC (it can just as well be this thread, with minor adjustments) would serve slightly better.

 

[DeletedUser]

It doesn't really work well, as showcase is... well... showcase. A dedicated thread for CnC (it can just as well be this thread, with minor adjustments) would serve slightly better.

I agree, numerical value and c+c would be really good

 

[DeletedUser]

GE-Simple but kinda effective i would give it 7/10

 

[DeletedUser]

aligman7

7/10 nice, but the text is a bit too far to the left that the D is not too visible ​

 

[DeletedUser]

DA

8/10 I dont like the picture or the text
The background is great, the guy doesnt look like he fits, and the font is almost too simple for the background its on. Maybe make the text pop out a bit, 3d or something

 

[DeletedUser]

Ankaar

6/10 I like it but the text seems to be the main feature unless this is what you were hoping for i usually like to have a picture to look at then the text as a second view point.

 

[DeletedUser]

8/10 - Its sex.

 

[mattoematt]

10/10 - Made me LoL

 

[DeletedUser]

10/10 - Made me LoL

hehe i made that :3

(ignore my post comment on his ^^^)

 

[DeletedUser]

At Radarr babes (this is xosoloxi ^^)

10/10 - You made it = win

 

[DeletedUser]

4/10 the mixture of images I dont like, ive always liked em better when they blend well