The problem is you're arguing semantics in a milestone thread you didn't create. The rules were left to the thread makers discretion. If you disagree, then make your own.
As it stands now, the first tribe to have 200 ennoblements hasn't been decided yet. Like Liquid was trying to point out to you, boo! recruited players with multiple vills. Those vills weren't boo! ennoblements, so they won't be counted towards their milestone.
And yeah, that means tribes like R.Inc can't really be competitive because they are relatively new tribes. But they chose to do things a certain way, such as =SK= getting disbanded and then re-formed under a new name. It would have been simple to do a name change and keep all the stats, but they went a different route.
Hope that helps you understand.