The difference here is the fact that skilled players (both in Chump and Toggles) are involved and skilled (meaning gamers whom have been in multiple premades with multiple trust risks) players don't hose over one another in a deceiving fashion. Furthermore, dukes don't allow skilled players to hose one or the other because it reflects poorly on their leadership skills.
Truth is, Toggles and Chump were in the same tribe, using the same skype community chat, the same internals and the same duke. One account deceived the other and in that tarnished both their name and the leadership of where?'s names.
and... now one can say that RAGE has also been tarnished (at least the leadership of RAGE)
Clearly put... yes, sometimes 500 pt accounts get the shaft but when two top accounts with top players in a top tribe suffer this.... well, its deserving of the negative pnp.