Cold food chef:
Location 5/10, tight cluster meaning only a few churches but also no room for expansion. 2 small villages near fire which will need some time to build so a 5/10 from me.
Farming 2/10, very low amount of resources plundered daily. Also a very very low amount of villages plundered.
Profile 6/10, looks a bit boring. I do think you have a passion for animals which I can appreciate.
Tribe 7/10, Order looks like a relatively good tribe on this world with decent leadership. Location is not bad but they would need to expand near fire to have a better front (in my opinion).
Villages 6/10, many low point villages. An average of around 7k for each village means a lot of resources still need to be spent on buildings. This will slow your growth and drop you in rank.
Overall a 5.2/10. Good luck getting it up, if you put in the effort on the points I made I think you can get a higher rating.