DeletedUser
Guest
Seeing as Raavna may be MIA I figure i'll start another tribe review thread of my own with the intention of keeping it updated. I'll be rating each tribe out of 100. I'll have 10 categories and score each one out of 10, because simple math suits me.
The Good Fellas
Points: 10/10
The Good Fellas
No. 1 tribe in the world with a 100k lead over AM family and nearly double the points of the rank 5 tribe. The numbers speak for themselves. Not much to comment about. Good work guys.
Position: 6/10
Not a great position or spread pretty bunched up in k45. While it's important to secure your k getting stuck in the core and gangbanged from all sides is never a fun time. It's definitely something that could happen lest they start heading towards the rim or get some friends back there pretty soon. Being number one is a just having a nice big target on your back.
Enoblements: 8/10
Impressive nobling. Very few barbs and internals. They've only lost one village so far to another tribe that wasn't recaptured. Only one tribe is beating them in villas captured so far this month.
Oda/Odd: 8/10
I've never been a huge fan of od in particular the less of it the better imo. They're no. 1 in oda and 6 in odd showing they've been doing a lot of beating up on other tribes while getting a fair share of it back in retaliation. They have the highest odd of the other top 5 tribes at 290k and nearly 3 times less then the rank 1 tribe in odd. Pretty good numbers considering.
Diplomacy: 6/10
Personally if i could i'd never get into a relationship with any tribe if i could help it. Hugging, nap's, alliances, coalitions, family tribes,etc.; Never had captivated my imagination. While i can see the importance of them and respect the people who can wheel and deal in the diplo department it's just not my style. Although with the tribe limit being only 25 members diplomacy will play a major role in w88. As far as i know Fellas has no diplomacy that i can speak of. While i can get behind that i can also see if it stays that way they will have a hard time before too long.
Coa/ Profile: 6/10
Soso for the coa/ profile gets the job done. That's about all though. I guess i like a little more showmanship enticing players.
Reputation: 7/10
Recognize a few players from previous worlds. Not much presence on the externals which isn't always a bad thing. Being rank one always helps your rep.
Recruitment: 7/10
4 players in the top 10. Birds of a feather flock together i guess. Like i mentioned before not a huge fan of the spread which could be improved if they recruited for position rather then rank as it looks. Still you can't argue with the current results. They have the 3rd highest tribe changes for the top 5. Considering they're not a premade it's to be expected. Can't fault a tribe for the comings and goings of players.
Tribe Appeal: 8/10
It's the number one tribe with some top ranked players that are growing well together, what's not appealing about that. Seriously though from the outside looking in it seems like they have things going in the right direction and plenty of people would love to get an invite.
Potential: 7/10
Going from past experiences it's pretty rare that the no.1 tribe from start up has what it takes to win a world. It's a long way off and we just got this world started. Overall though Fellas have definitely set themselves up on the right foot to give it a good run. With a bit of luck and some well placed diplomacy who knows what could happen.
Total Score: 79/100
The dukes of Fellas have been kind enough to answer a few questions for me as well:
