You're making a strawman argument.
I said premium features are more popular than limited hauls.
I did not say worlds with premium features are more popular than worlds without them are.
Limited hauls and no hauls have always statistically been the least popular settings.
The game also by no means drives out F2P players and leaves P2W players behind.
If that were the case this wouldn't happen on worlds:
Rank Name Tribe Points Villages Points per village
1
KGBRomeo
Next 277.823 39 7124
2
1st ENEX
Next 195.730 23 8510
3
mrhoangdh
Next 104.802 23 4557
The reason that happens is because very few people actually opt to spend much money. Specifically 2 out of 9993 players on that world spend a large amount of money.
Didn't exactly leave behind P2W players when 99.9799% of the players are spending minimal amounts of money.
So, yes, there are faulty observations being made - by you.