I followed this for a while, and it is just getting funny.
While I was kinda pissed when PK sniped one of our high ranking members, the other two they wrote to decided to stay with us. If the other guy feels happier with them, more power to him. I told all of my members that if they want to leave for a bigger tribe, they are welcome to, no hard feelings.
My co-Duke was annoyed, but he listened to me when I told him that it would be quite ridiculous to start some crap over something like this. Apparently Ori did not realize this, and instead of writing a simple 'Hey, could you please stop trying to steal our members' they made rather pathetic demands. Now they are getting their asses handed to them.
Talib, why the hell would Scorpion want to attack you? You're losing troops all over the place, while all he has to do is repair his wall. While you're breaking your teeth on him, the rest of his tribe can continue to farm others, grow, and send him some support if needed. You on the other hand are wasting resources that could have gone towards strengthening your tribe, and you're pissing away troops leaving yourself open.
And yes, of course what Scorpion is posting here is propaganda. That's the point of posting in a forum like this. Would you posting something along the lines of 'Yay, we are losing. They are kicking our ass'? No, you'd put the best spin on it that you possibly could.
Sorry for the long post from somebody who's not even involved, but Talib, you really should find another spokesperson for your tribe. And maybe get a five year old to review all your plans. If he can find the obvious flaws, shitcan the plan.