DeletedUser51929
Guest
If the comption scores where like golf I'd be a shoe in >
No. 5 - Rockshine - I like both of these sigs once again but I can't help but notice the line of lightness difference ? to the right hand side of matt's attempt, just doesn't look right to me. Very good sig by Rockshine, this was also a tough call.
Was actually testing out an effect... which by your post went wrong :lol: But I was expecting to lose anyway and Rockshine's entry was exceptional. Glad i'm going to lose against a piece worth losing against!
Meh, 7:6 to dirty trick. =/
Okay...
Miister Man vs. Geremy
I don't really feel the need to go over everything in depth. Miister Man gets my vote, because Geremy's seems to be nothing but text. =/
Miller d vs. Genetic Engineer
Miller's has a fine coat of pointless dots on it which really puts me off. The background colours green and purple just don't mix and the render isn't blended much. GE; good lighting, some great effects on the piece, though the focal of the render is smack bang in the middle and the curvy thing, which i assume is coming out of the instrument, looks more like it goes behind it. Even so, my vote here goes to GE.
Jaysizzle vs. RSI
Jay; the C4Ds just seem misplaced, as they are all over the focal and really draw away attention. It's sort of like drawing attention from the focal to the focal, but to the wrong part of the focal?
RSI; I'm not a fan of the borders much, though they aren't as bad as they could have been. I don't like the black and white too much either, i think it would have been much better in colour. On the other hand, the lighting is great and i absolutely love the text. The render is well blended and there is even some suggestion of low. You definitely get my vote on this one.
Matt vs. rockshine
Matt; i just don't quite get the (perhaps) over-saturation of colour, expecially around his leg. Also, you could have done a bit more to support the 'Explosion of sound' idea.
Rockshine; I feel in this sig black and white works really well, and makes the slight splashes of colour around the focal really stick out well. A good use of wireframe C4Ds, they aren't necessarily easy to get right. I would complain about the lack of border and text, but it actually works well to complement the sig. Today you get my vote.
"siggy rules"
"too much text"
i'm sorry but from my point of view as someone that does get paid for his per diem work
[spoil][/spoil]
you have really done yourselves an injustice here.....I'm just not going to be nice about this anymore, leave you all as master of your domains, and go back to my commissioned work and the occasional sig request.
i knew i should have stayed as far away as possible from this group
"siggy rules"
"too much text"
i'm sorry but from my point of view as someone that does get paid for his per diem work
[spoil][/spoil]
you have really done yourselves an injustice here.....I'm just not going to be nice about this anymore, leave you all as master of your domains, and go back to my commissioned work and the occasional sig request.
i knew i should have stayed as far away as possible from this group
"siggy rules"
"too much text"
i'm sorry but from my point of view as someone that does get paid for his per diem work
[spoil][/spoil]
you have really done yourselves an injustice here.....I'm just not going to be nice about this anymore, leave you all as master of your domains, and go back to my commissioned work and the occasional sig request.
i knew i should have stayed as far away as possible from this group
"siggy rules"
"too much text"
i'm sorry but from my point of view as someone that does get paid for his per diem work
[spoil][/spoil]
you have really done yourselves an injustice here.....I'm just not going to be nice about this anymore, leave you all as master of your domains, and go back to my commissioned work and the occasional sig request.
i knew i should have stayed as far away as possible from this group
I understand exactly how you feel. I am also a professional in this, and sometimes the lack of judgement in pieces is disturbing. .lol. So let me clarify my judgment then. The piece itself was good, my problem was with the word hell, which is a word that would be questionable in a signature. In advertising, as I am sure you know, we do have to hit our target market, while complying with any restrictions there might be.