Hrm. Well. I did say I was out, but... I believe this deserves a response of some sort, and given you're claiming to be new, m'willing to be gentle.
how can you place such a inaccurate opinion on someone based on one - admitidly careless attack -
Where's the inaccuracy? Openeye has looked into TW stats, and I've outlined three possible scenarios based on the evidence so far provided. I don't actually think either of us really ventured an 'opinion', other than to remark from the looks of things, TribalBlaze appears newb, and he's not a leader I'd choose to follow, knowing the information at hand.
But to answer the general question, we (or at least, I) can do so because from the looks of things, he's being hypocritical, and clearly distorting the truth of the situation. And I'm not much of a fan of either such tactic.
When he chooses to defend himself, I'm willing to listen. Until such a time though,
m'not willing to jump on the bandwagon of instanty shunning a player who appears to have every right to have posted this thread.
I understand you're most likely to take the side of your leader, as you're in his tribe, s'only to be expected. But if you objectively read the points openeye and I made, I think it's pretty obvious we're quite entitled to the bare minimum of what 'opinion' we've shared.
Iyyyy said:
Not too mention from a player who would sulk on the wforums about his getting nobled, suck it up and find a in new village cos there ours now >
Are you seriously suggesting that if you'd been account sat, had trusted your leader to look into your building levels, troops, village plans etc, then that same leader turned around and nobled you, you wouldn't be slightly put out? M'pretty sure most people would, whether they wish to admit it or not. Especially on W33, where any loss is particularly hard, given the crazy slow speed.
I wouldn't classify this thread as 'sulking', so much as expressing dissatisfaction. And with what's been uncovered so far, m'not terribly surprised there's dissatisfaction.
Still patiently awaiting the other side's response, though.