Rate The Above Player

DeletedUser

Guest
Thought i'd bring this here to boost activity on the forum:

In each of these categories:


  • Forum Presence
  • Points
  • Starting Position
  • Overall
Judge the player that posted last with a score out of 10, with a little explanation behind each choice.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Modern man

* seems to talk sense on the forums 8/10
* not in top 100, but judging from his neighbors' points he has lotsa troops. 9/10
* Nice Iron Bonus should start coming in handy 8/10
* Dunno him good enough yet */10

EDIT: @ Jakelo: Who said I want to be rated LOL. dUh.Vi11aGe.iDi8t
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser

Guest
Maby it could be handy to put your IGN in your last post then.
 

max vs george

Guest
5/10
N/A (don't know)
N/A (don't know)
3/10 (partly because don't know)
 

DeletedUser89403

Guest
7/10 it's a little low because you kept asking for a coplayer.
10/10 ranked 5 overall
6/10 2 barbs touching but Icey Hot is right next to
you
8/10 you are obviously good.
 

max vs george

Guest
6/10 I only seen 1 or two posts from you
8/10 26th aint bad
9/10 Spoilt because of tribe member being in your 7x7
8/10 :)

Just to point out, Icey Hot is going to be co-playing for me now.


*edit I made those barbs go barb :)
 

Ripfin

Guest
5/10 neutral since don't know you but on the other hand a 1/10 for having a co-player.
8/10 in the top 5
10/10 right next to a wood bonus village the dream of all starting players
7/10 your a farmer.
 

max vs george

Guest
8/10 People seem to like you
6/10 Top 120, not bad I guess but not too fancy
9/10 Got 2 barbs and two bonus villas under an hour away
8/10 I like you


Plus is "your a farmer." a compliment?
 

Ripfin

Guest
max vs george said:
8/10 People seem to like you
6/10 Top 120, not bad I guess but not too fancy
9/10 Got 2 barbs and two bonus villas under an hour away
8/10 I like you


Plus is "your a farmer." a compliment?
Click to expand...

yes it means your out farming and not sitting around.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Forum Presence 10/10
I remember nub being epically pwned by Zevahc
Points 6/10
Not that im much better prob around 3/10 his should be higher if he is following a 2:1 ratio
Starting Position 5/10
Its an acceptable position for his area
Overall 8/10
I think hes a good guy who knows what hes doing and im glade im not near him, Couldn't say who would come out on top.

(like this?)
 
Last edited by a moderator:

DeletedUser

Guest
Ripfin:

Forum Presence: 7/10
Actively contributes to forum discussion and contributes to keeping the forum interesting.

Points: 10/10
Not too high or too low for this early stage of the world. Has obviously resisted the temptation to rise quickly in the ranking and instead invested in early troop production.

Starting Position: 9/10
Could only be better if some of those bonus villages/farms were slightly closer, but still, a very nice spread of farms and future noble targets.

Overall: 8/10
From what i've seen; a good quality player that not only plays well but contributes to the social side of the game as well.
 

max vs george

Guest
Forum: 9/10 seen you been respected a lot
Points: 5/10 under 200, not a lot
Starting Position: 5/10 most people are bigger, 1 barb
Overall: 7/10 meh


*edit for Shadow
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Forum: 9/10 Ten/ten is only for me! lol
Points: 9/10 Top ten player.
Starting Position: 5/10 Few villages to farm but not bad, at least you can breathe!
Overall: 8/10 Good player, good points, good awards, active in forum, good skills in sending restart mails!... what else do we need?
 

max vs george

Guest
9/10 Ten/ten isn't only for you! Stop being selfish :(
5/10 Not too exciting sorry :(
4/10 Got 2 barbs but the rest is just too crowded for my likings
8/10 Like you, you're my fangirl xD
 

DeletedUser

Guest
Forum: 9/10 I get a kick out of reading your post.
Points: 9/10 Top ten player. Enough said.
Starting Position: 7/10 Not a great one but you make it work
Overall: 8/10 one of those players that im glade im not near.
 

DeletedUser

Guest
max vs george said:
9/10 Ten/ten isn't only for you! Stop being selfish :(
5/10 Not too exciting sorry :(
4/10 Got 2 barbs but the rest is just too crowded for my likings
8/10 Like you, you're my fangirl xD
Click to expand...

lol, those villages are better than barbs! I love my starting position.
 

max vs george

Guest
If you had access to my account you'd be happy where I am now.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top