MichielK
Guest
i dont like the deserver a rank one cause if a tribe deserved a high rank they would have one and same for a lower rank
I disagree. There are many ways to gain a temporary advantage in rank: mass-recruitment, merging, not eating inactives. However, these do not advance the tribe as a whole. The "deserves a ... rank" question allows us to indicate who got their rank the right way, and who got it the wrong way.
STAR (who already renamed themselves twice this week) is a good example. They merged and recruited themselves into the top 10, but are clearly inferior to some of the tribes below them. Ad Inf is 6th but losing by a wide margin in their first war ever. On the other hand, a tribe like Dust is holding their own against a much bigger foe.
STAR and Ad Inf deserve a lower rank, while Dust deserves a higher rank. If I'm right about this, it's only a matter of time until it happens...and that's what the question is about, IMO.