I thought I'd actually respond to the original post, though in an abbreviated form...
Most Feared Player: Any one of the top ten could be cited but, realistically, the player with the most vills and longest track record if being offensive has to be the "man". Clearly Zain is the most offensive ;-)
Your Favourite Player(s): Logan amuses me ;-)
Most Disliked Player(s): SN the player. As a human being a suspect he'd be a laugh
Most Promising Non Top 40 player(s): Promising? At this stage? If someone had promise they'd be at the top already.
Your Favourite Tribe: Aside from Apoc, probably =V= for their sheer bloody-mindedness!
Least Liked Tribe: TF. This is more a comment on its leadership. I like many (if not most) of the old Apoc-W guys (I don't know the folks recruited from the east) but the leadership's egos have truly screwed the tribe over.
Most Promising Non Top 5 Tribe: At this point I suspect those outside the top 5 will eventually merge with those in it (or be overwhelmed).
Best Leader: Actually I'm stumped with this one given Peter is no longer a leader within BA. I think Jackie Barry & Masterfool101 probably get the prize.
Worst Leader: Cal- & Rattlesnake8. Easy.
Most Entertaining P&P poster: I do like Peter's posts but they have a tendency to demand a little too much effort to read (Sorry Peter!)
Worst Forum Personality: With AA in stealth mode this has to be SN by a country mile.
Best Tribe Representation: Aside from Apoc (of course) then BA.
Best Thread Thus Far (provide links if you can): W18 Map Thread. It is and will always be the king of threads, though an update would be nice ;-)
Best Avatar: No idea or interest.
Best Signature: As above.
Most Experierienced/Skilled player: As I have no idea who plays which of the enemies players anymore I will have to vote for one of my own... Sechul Lath
Given that the rest of the categories are variations on a theme I think I will quit there!